Creating Social Science Theory bridges a critical gap in social science education by providing a comprehensive guide to natural language theory development.
Shoemaker and Lacy expertly demystify the theorizing process, demonstrating that theory creation is distinct from-yet complementary to-statistical testing. Through clear explanations and practical frameworks, the authors guide readers through exploration, visualization, and explication of theoretical concepts and statements, offering standardized guidelines for presenting complete theories that have been sorely missing from the field. Readers will learn how to visualize relationships, explicate concepts, and evaluate theoretical statements-skills essential for creating new theories or revising existing ones. With discussions on causation, boundary conditions, and the potential role of artificial intelligence in theorizing, this text provides a thorough foundation for understanding how theories can be developed, tested, and refined.
By addressing the imbalance between methodology and theory in graduate education, this book equips the next generation of scholars with the tools to advance theoretical knowledge in communication, media studies, political science, psychology, sociology, and behavioral economics.
Inhaltsverzeichnis
Foreword
Preface
1 Theorizing
Social science theory
Ways of knowing
The scientific method
Causality
Summary
2 Thinking
Fast and slow thinking
Thinking in the sciences
Creative thinking
Critical thinking
Theoretical thinking
Summary
3 Exploration
Systems thinking
Reasoning and logic
Logical fallacies of informal logic
Abstracting and generalizing
Theorizing with time
Exploring concepts
Exploring assumptions
Exploring boundary conditions
Summary
4 Visualizing Relationships
Visualization and the brain
Forms of visualization
Functions of visualization in theorizing
Relationships with multiple concepts
Visual models
Summary
5 Explicating Concepts
Disciplines and their levels of analysis
Labeling concepts
Theoretically defining concepts
Types of concepts
Potential problems
Summary
6 Explicating Theoretical Statements
Specifying boundary conditions and assumptions
Verbalizing simple theoretical statements
Verbalizing complex theoretical statements
Reciprocal relationships
Theoretical linkages
Ordering definitions and linkages
Verbalizing relationships within models
Do-it-yourself model building
Summary
7 Guidelines for Presenting Complete Theories
Identifying theory is difficult
Theory elements
Making a theory complete
Formatting is important for theory
Guidelines for formatting social science theory
Placement of elements
Ad hoc theory formats
Summary
8 Evaluating Theories
A useful theory
Criteria for evaluating theories
Less useful theories
When to evaluate a theory
Summary
9 From Theorizing to Testing
Why test theories
How theories are tested
Operationalizing concepts
Operationalizing theoretical statements
Creating the research design
Selecting samples
Collecting data
Applying statistical procedures
Evaluating research results
Summary
10 Advancing Knowledge
The origins of knowledge
Intersubjective agreement
The body of social science knowledge
Summary
Glossary
Index