The university is a foundational institution in society and a cornerstone of democracy. However, recent actions taken by the Trump administration pose an existential threat to this institution by undermining its singular animating right: academic freedom. In Academic Freedom in the Era of Trump, preeminent thinkers draw from their experience as university leaders and First Amendment scholars to portray this troubling moment for academic freedom. The volume examines the legal, historical, and philosophical foundations of academic freedom, its First Amendment roots, and the implications of recent political interference. The Supreme Court has now enshrined the principle of academic freedom within our First Amendment jurisprudence, unceasingly affirming the principle while continuing to refine its contours. Yet, the Trump administration has employed an authoritarian playbook to assault this principle, withholding federal research funding and exploiting antidiscrimination laws, among other tactics. To prevail in this moment, universities must defend academic freedom by clarifying and reaffirming the constitutional origins, emphasizing the indispensable societal role, and refining and articulating the distinct culture and structures of universities that allow the principle to flourish. Urgent and timely, this book offers a powerful defense of the university as a space for free inquiry and democratic resilience.
Inhaltsverzeichnis
- Opening Dialogue
- Part I The History of Academic Freedom in the United States and the Arrival of the Trump Administration
- 1: Robert C. Post: The Assault on Academic Freedom
- 2: Cass R. Sunstein: "Our Money or Your Life!" Higher Education and the First Amendment
- 3: Nicholas B. Dirks: Academic Freedom, Ideological Capture, and the Autonomy of the University
- 4: Niall Ferguson: Executive Authority and Academic Freedom
- Part II The Authoritarian Playbook on Academic Freedom: Federal Funding
- 5: Erwin Chemerinsky: The Trump Administration's Assault on Academic Freedom: Controlling Funds as a Way to Impermissibly Control Universities
- 6: Mary-Rose Papandrea: Money, Money, Money: Universities, Government Funding, and Academic Freedom
- 7: Aziz Z. Huq: The End of the Cold War University
- Part III The Authoritarian Playbook on Academic Freedom: Civil Rights and Antidiscrimination
- 8: Robert Shibley and Nadine Strossen: Title VI Rights and Wrongs: Campuses Must Bar Discrimination Against Both Identities and Ideas
- 9: Olatunde Johnson: Equal Protection and Academic Freedom
- 10: Mary Anne Franks: Little Fascists Everywhere: The National Socialist Playbook of Trump's War on Universities
- Part IV The Authoritarian Playbook on Academic Freedom: Courts and Immigration
- 11: Leah M. Litman: Courting Higher Ed: How Right-Wing Attacks on Higher Education Mimic Their Attacks on the Courts
- 12: Ilya Somin: How Speech-Based Immigration Restrictions Threaten Academic Freedom
- Part V University Culture and Its Contribution to the Demise of Academic Freedom
- 13: Tom Ginsburg: The American Attack on Academic Freedom in Comparative Perspective
- 14: Louis Michael Seidman: Academic Freedom and the Progressive Crackup
- 15: Suzanna Sherry: Academic Freedom and Academic Orthodoxy
- 16: Larry Kramer and Lee C. Bollinger: Committing to Intellectual Fallibility: The Improper Use of Academic Freedom to Limit Speech
- Part VI The Future of Academic Freedom: Understanding What's at Stake and Forming a Response
- 17: Randall L. Kennedy: Private Universities, Freedom, and Federal Power in the Trump Era: The Case of Harvard
- 18: M. Elizabeth Magill: Persuading the Unpersuaded
- 19: Steven G. Poskanzer: Stances in Defense of Institutional Academic Freedom
- 20: Amy Gutmann And Lee Bollinger: What's the Danger of the Trump Administration's Demands on Universities?