Inductive Logic is number ten in the 11-volume Handbook of the History of Logic. While there are many examples were a science split from philosophy and became autonomous (such as physics with Newton and biology with Darwin), and while there are, perhaps, topics that are of exclusively philosophical interest, inductive logic - as this handbook attests - is a research field where philosophers and scientists fruitfully and constructively interact. This handbook covers the rich history of scientific turning points in Inductive Logic, including probability theory and decision theory. Written by leading researchers in the field, both this volume and the Handbook as a whole are definitive reference tools for senior undergraduates, graduate students and researchers in the history of logic, the history of philosophy, and any discipline, such as mathematics, computer science, cognitive psychology, and artificial intelligence, for whom the historical background of his or her work is a salient consideration.
- Chapter on the Port Royal contributions to probability theory and decision theory
- Serves as a singular contribution to the intellectual history of the 20th century
- Contains the latest scholarly discoveries and interpretative insights
Inhaltsverzeichnis
1;Front Cover ;1 2;Inductive Logic ;4 3;Copyright Page ;5 4;Contents;6 5;Introduction;8 6;Contributors;10 7;Induction Before Hume;14 7.1;1 The Ancient World;14 7.2;2 The Middle Ages;27 7.3;3 The Renaissance;33 7.4;4 The Seventeenth Century and Early Eighteenth Century;36 7.5;5 Conclusion;49 7.6;Bibliography;50 8;Hume and the Problem of Induction;56 8.1;1 Introduction;56 8.2;2 Two Problems of Induction;58 8.3;3 Hume's Fork: The First Option;60 8.4;4 Hume's Fork: The Second Option;68 8.5;5 Three Ways of Rejecting Hume's Problem;74 8.6;6 Hume's Conclusion;80 8.7;7 Bonjour's a Priori Justification of Induction;83 8.8;8 Reichenbach's Pragmatic Justification of Induction;87 8.9;9 Bayesian Approaches;93 8.10;10 Williams' Combinatorial Justification of Induction;96 8.11;11 The Inductive Leap as Mythical;99 8.12;12 Conclusion;101 8.13;Bibliography;101 9;The Debate between Whewell and Mill on the Nature of Scientific Induction;106 9.1;1 Why the Debate is not Merely Terminological;106 9.2;2 The Kepler Example and the Colligation of Facts;108 9.3;3 Whewell's Tests of Hypotheses;115 9.4;4 Disputes about Induction that have Ignored these Lessons;118 9.5;5 Implications for Probabilistic Theories of Evidence and Confirmation;122 9.6;Acknowledgements;127 9.7;Bibliography;127 10;An Explorer Upon Untrodden Ground: Peirce on Abduction;130 10.1;1 Introduction;130 10.2;2 Ideas from Kant and Aristotle;131 10.3;3 Peirce's Two-Dimensional Framework;133 10.4;4 Hypothesis vs Induction;137 10.5;5 The Road to Abduction;144 10.6;6 From the Instinctive to the Reasoned Marks of Truth;149 10.7;7 The Three Stages of Inquiry;156 10.8;8 Looking Ahead;160 10.9;Further Reading;163 10.10;Bibliography;163 11;The Modern Epistemic Interpretations of Probability: Logicism and Subjectivism;166 11.1;1 The Logical Interpretation of Probability;166 11.2;2 The Subjective Interpretation of Probability;190 11.3;Concluding Remarks;209 11.4;Bibliography;210 12;Popper and Hypothetico-Deductivism;218 12.1;Enthymemes an
d their Deductivist Reconstructions;219 12.2;'Automobile Logic';220 12.3;Formal and Semantic Validity;221 12.4;Historical Interlude: Mill Versus Aristotle;223 12.5;Wittgensteinian Instrumentalism;228 12.6;'Logic of Discovery' Deductive or Inductive?;231 12.7;'Logic of Justification' Deductive or Inductive?;238 12.8;Getting Started 'Foundational Beliefs';245 12.9;Bibliography;246 13;Hempel and the Paradoxes of Confirmation;248 13.1;1 Towards a Logic of Confirmation;248 13.2;2 Adequacy Criteria;251 13.3;3 The Satisfaction Criterion;254 13.4;4 The Raven Paradox;259 13.5;5 The Bayesian's Raven Paradox;265 13.6;6 Summary;273 13.7;Acknowledgements;274 13.8;Bibliography;274 14;Carnap and the Logic of Inductive Inference;278 14.1;1 Introduction;278 14.2;2 Probability;278 14.3;3 Confirmation;282 14.4;4 Exchangeability;284 14.5;5 The Continuum of Inductive Methods;287 14.6;6 Confirmation of Universal Generalizations;291 14.7;7 Instantial Relevance;294 14.8;8 Finite Exchangeability;295 14.9;9 The First Induction Theorem;301 14.10;10 Analogy;301 14.11;11 The Sampling of Species Problem;307 14.12;12 A Budget of Paradoxes;309 14.13;13 Carnap Redux;312 14.14;14 Conclusion;318 14.15;Bibliography;318 15;The Development of the Hintikka Program;324 15.1;1 Inductive Logic as a Methodological Research Program;324 15.2;2 From Carnap to Hintikka's Two-Dimensional Continuum;328 15.3;3 Axiomatic Inductive Logic;335 15.4;4 Extensions of Hintikka's System;338 15.5;5 Semantic Information;342 15.6;6 Confirmation and Acceptance;345 15.7;7 Cognitive Decision Theory;347 15.8;8 Inductive Logic and Theories;350 15.9;9 Analogy and Observational Errors;353 15.10;10 Truthlikeness;356 15.11;11 Machine Learning;359 15.12;12 Evaluation of the Hintikka Program;362 15.13;Bibliography;365 16;Hans Reichenbach's Probability Logic;370 16.1;1 Introduction;370 16.2;2 Probability Logic: The Basic Set-Up;373 16.3;3 Probabilities as Limiting Frequencies;376 16.4;4 Probability Logic;382 16.5;5 Critics: Popper, Nagel
and Russell;390 16.6;6 Reichenbach on the Attempts of others and on Standard Problems;395 16.7;7 Commentary;397 16.8;Bibliography;400 17;Goodman and the Demise of Syntactic and Semantic Models;404 17.1;1 Historical Background;404 17.2;2 Developments in the Twentieth Century;406 17.3;3 The New Riddle of Induction;408 17.4;4 Some Misunderstandings;410 17.5;5 Proposed Asymmetries;412 17.6;6 The Entrenchment Solution;414 17.7;7 Implications;416 17.8;8 Values, Virtues and Hypothesis Selection;419 17.9;Bibliography;424 18;The Development of Subjective Bayesianism;428 18.1;2 The Problem of the Priors;436 18.2;3 Inductive Inference as Updating Subjective Probability;460 18.3;4 Subjective Probability and Objective Chance;471 18.4;5 Conclusion;485 18.5;Bibliography;486 19;Varieties of Bayesianism;490 19.1;1 Introduction;490 19.2;2 Interpretations of Probability;498 19.3;3 The Subjective-Objective Continuum;506 19.4;4 Justifications;529 19.5;5 Decision Theory;540 19.6;6 Confirmation Theory;547 19.7;7 Theories of Belief (A.K.A. Acceptance);553 19.8;8 Summary;558 19.9;Bibliography;559 20;Inductive Logic and Empirical Psychology;566 20.1;Introduction;566 20.2;1 The Bayesian Approach to Cognition;570 20.3;2 Language;577 20.4;3 Inductive Reasoning;584 20.5;4 Deductive Reasoning;590 20.6;5 Decision Making;606 20.7;6 Argumentation;614 20.8;7 Challenges and Future Directions;618 20.9;Conclusion;622 20.10;Acknowledgements;623 20.11;Bibliography;623 21;Inductive Logic and Statistics;638 21.1;1 From Inductive Logic to Statistics;638 21.2;2 Observational Data;639 21.3;3 Inductive Inference;641 21.4;4 Carnapian Logics;643 21.5;5 Bayesian Statistics;645 21.6;6 Inductive Logic with Hypotheses;648 21.7;7 Neyman-Pearson Testing;650 21.8;8 Neyman-Pearson Test as an Inference;653 21.9;9 Fisher's Parameter Estimation;656 21.10;10 Estimations in Inductive Logic;657 21.11;11 Fiducial Probability;659 21.12;12 In Conclusion;661 21.13;Acknowledgements;662 21.14;Bibliography;662 22;Statistical Learning
Theory: Models, Concepts, and Results;664 22.1;1 Introduction;664 22.2;2 The Standard Framework of Statistical Learning Theory;664 22.3;3 Consistency and Generalization for the K-Nearest Neighbor Classifier;677 22.4;4 Empirical Risk Minimization;680 22.5;5 Capacity Concepts and Generalization Bounds;686 22.6;6 Incorporating Knowledge into the Bounds;696 22.7;7 The Approximation Error and Bayes Consistency;700 22.8;8 No Free Lunch Theorem;705 22.9;9 Model Based Approaches to Learning;708 22.10;10 The vc Dimension, Popper's Dimension, and the Number of Parameters;715 22.11;11 Conclusion;717 22.12;Acknowledgements;717 22.13;Bibliography;718 23;Formal Learning Theory in Context;720 23.1;Introduction;720 23.2;The Character of Formal Learning Theory;720 23.3;Confidence Intervals;725 23.4;Comparison;728 23.5;Conclusion;729 23.6;Bibliography;730 24;Mechanizing Induction;732 24.1;1 Machine Learning and Computational Learning Theory;732 24.2;2 Nonmonotonic Reasoning;751 24.3;Acknowledgements;779 24.4;Bibliography;779 25;Index;786