Everyone makes decisions, but not everyone is a decision analyst. A decision analyst uses quantitative models and computational methods to formulate decision algorithms, assess decision performance, identify and evaluate options, determine trade-offs and risks, evaluate strategies for investigation, and so on. Info-Gap Decision Theory is written for decision analysts.
The term "decision analyst" covers an extremely broad range of practitioners. Virtually all engineers involved in design (of buildings, machines, processes, etc.) or analysis (of safety, reliability, feasibility, etc.) are decision analysts, usually without calling themselves by this name. In addition to engineers, decision analysts work in planning offices for public agencies, in project management consultancies, they are engaged in manufacturing process planning and control, in financial planning and economic analysis, in decision support for medical or technological diagnosis, and so on and on. Decision analysts provide quantitative support for the decision-making process in all areas where systematic decisions are made.
This second edition entails changes of several sorts. First, info-gap theory has found application in several new areas - especially biological conservation, economic policy formulation, preparedness against terrorism, and medical decision-making. Pertinent new examples have been included. Second, the combination of info-gap analysis with probabilistic decision algorithms has found wide application. Consequently "hybrid" models of uncertainty, which were treated exclusively in a separate chapter in the previous edition, now appear throughout the book as well as in a separate chapter. Finally, info-gap explanations of robust-satisficing behavior, and especially the Ellsberg and Allais "paradoxes", are discussed in a new chapter together with a theorem indicating when robust-satisficing will have greater probability of success than direct optimizing with uncertain models.
- New theory developed systematically
- Many examples from diverse disciplines
- Realistic representation of severe uncertainty
- Multi-faceted approach to risk
- Quantitative model-based decision theory
Inhaltsverzeichnis
1;Front Cover;1 2;Contents;6 3;Preface to the 1st edition;12 4;Preface to the 2nd edition;14 5;1 Overview;18 6;2 Uncertainty;26 6.1;2.1 Historical Perspective;26 6.2;2.2 Is Ignorance Probabilistic?;29 6.3;2.3 Info-Gap Uncertainty, Probability and Fuzziness;31 6.4;2.4 Uncertainty and Convexity;35 6.5;2.5 Some Info-Gap Models;37 6.6;2.6 Axioms of Info-Gap Uncertainty;48 6.7;2.7 Problems;49 7;3 Robustness and Opportuneness;54 7.1;3.1 Robustness and Opportuneness;55 7.1.1;3.1.1 A First Look;55 7.1.2;3.1.2 Immunity Functions;56 7.1.3;3.1.3 Generic Decision Algorithms;58 7.1.4;3.1.4 Multi-Criterion Reward;60 7.1.5;3.1.5 Three Components of Info-Gap Decision Models;61 7.1.6;3.1.6 Preferences;62 7.1.7;3.1.7 Trade-Offs;63 7.1.8;3.1.8 Zero Robustness and Preference Reversal;65 7.2;3.2 Simple Examples;66 7.2.1;3.2.1 Engineering Design: Cantilever;67 7.2.2;3.2.2 Structural Reliability;71 7.2.3;3.2.3 Structural Reliability with Uncertain Probability;73 7.2.4;3.2.4 Set-Points for Process Control;75 7.2.5;3.2.5 Sequential Decisions;77 7.2.6;3.2.6 Project Scheduling with Uncertain Task Durations;81 7.2.7;3.2.7 Portfolio Investment;87 7.2.8;3.2.8 Monetary Policy;92 7.2.9;3.2.9 Search and Evasion;95 7.2.10;3.2.10 Assay Design: Environmental Monitoring;97 7.2.11;3.2.11 Bio-Terror Preparedness with Epidemiological Models;100 7.2.12;3.2.12 Drug Selection;103 7.2.13;3.2.13 Estimating an Uncertain Probability Density;105 7.3;3.3 Production Volume With Uncertain Costs;108 7.4;3.4 General Robustness and Opportuneness Functions;116 7.5;3.5 Problems;120 8;4 Value Judgments;132 8.1;4.1 Normalization;133 8.2;4.2 Analogical Reasoning;134 8.3;4.3 Calibration by Consequence Severity;138 8.3.1;4.3.1 Robustness Function for Environmental Management;138 8.3.2;4.3.2 Calibration by Consequence Severity;140 8.4;4.4 Rationality and Preference;141 8.5;4.5 Problems;144 9;5 Antagonistic and Sympathetic Immunities;146 9.1;5.1 Immunity Functions;147 9.2;5.2 Reward-Coherent Action;149 9.3;5.3 Vibrating Mechani
cal Contact;150 9.4;5.4 Multi-Tasking of Computer Jobs;154 9.4.1;5.4.1 Formulation;154 9.4.2;5.4.2 Deriving Robustness and Opportuneness Functions;157 9.4.3;5.4.3 Results;160 9.5;5.5 Problems;163 10;6 Gambling and Risk Sensitivity;166 10.1;6.1 Preview;167 10.2;6.2 Risk Sensitivity and the Robustness Curve;168 10.3;6.3 Risk Sensitivity and Two Robustness Curves;170 10.4;6.4 Initial Commitment and Uncertain Future;173 10.4.1;6.4.1 Uniformly Bounded Uncertainty;175 10.4.2;6.4.2 Ellipsoidal Fourier Uncertainty;177 10.5;6.5 Risk Sensitivity, Robustness and Opportuneness;177 10.6;6.6 Risk-Neutral Line;180 10.7;6.7 Pure Competition with Uncertain Cost;183 10.8;6.8 Interim Summary;186 10.9;6.9 Risk Assessment in Project Management;188 10.10;6.10 More on the Robustness Premium;189 10.11;6.11 Robustness Premium and Resource Commitment;193 10.12;6.12 Problems;196 11;7 Value of Information;202 11.1;7.1 Informativeness of an Info-Gap Model;203 11.2;7.2 Demand Value of Information;205 11.3;7.3 Uncertain Loads on a Cantilever;207 11.4;7.4 Cantilever: Simple and Complex Info-Gap Models;211 11.5;7.5 Gathering Information in Project Management;213 11.6;7.6 Windfall Cost of Information;214 11.6.1;7.6.1 Formulation;215 11.6.2;7.6.2 Discussion;216 11.7;7.7 Initial Commitment and Uncertain Future: Revisited;218 11.8;7.8 Problems;220 12;8 Learning;224 12.1;8.1 Learning and Deciding;224 12.2;8.2 Info-Gap Supervision of a Classifier;226 12.2.1;8.2.1 Robustness of a Classifier;226 12.2.2;8.2.2 Asymptotic Robustness;227 12.2.3;8.2.3 Robust-Optimal Classifier;229 12.2.4;8.2.4 A Proof;231 12.2.5;8.2.5 Robust Severe Tests of Truth;232 12.2.6;8.2.6 Updating Info-Gap Models;233 12.2.7;8.2.7 Plantar Pressures in Metatarsal Pathology;236 12.3;8.3 Acoustic Noise;239 12.3.1;8.3.1 Empirical Robustness;240 12.3.2;8.3.2 Updating the Acoustic Uncertainty Model;242 12.4;8.4 Summary;243 12.5;8.5 Problems;245 13;9 Coherent Uncertainties and Consensus;248 13.1;9.1 Preference Preservation Under Altered Informa
tion;249 13.2;9.2 Examples of Coherent Uncertainties;252 13.3;9.3 Principal-Agent Contract Bidding;258 13.4;9.4 Proofs;261 13.5;9.5 Problems;263 14;10 Hybrid Uncertainties;266 14.1;10.1 Info-Gap Uncertainty in a Poisson Process;267 14.2;10.2 Embedded Probability Densities;270 14.3;10.3 Example: Endangered Species;273 14.4;10.4 Example: Serving an Uncertain Queue;276 14.5;10.5 Probabilistic Info-Gap Parameter;279 14.6;10.6 Problems;281 15;11 Robust-Satisficing Behavior;284 15.1;11.1 The Ellsberg 'Paradox';285 15.2;11.2 The Allais 'Paradox';288 15.2.1;11.2.1 Formulation;289 15.2.2;11.2.2 Probability Uncertainty;290 15.2.3;11.2.3 Utility Uncertainty;293 15.3;11.3 Info-Gap Analysis of Expected-Utility Risk Aversion;294 15.4;11.4 Probability of Success;296 15.4.1;11.4.1 Robust-Satisficing and Direct-Optimizing;297 15.4.2;11.4.2 Satisficing and Survival;300 15.5;11.5 The Equity Premium Puzzle: A Solution;301 15.5.1;11.5.1 Introduction;301 15.5.2;11.5.2 Dynamics, Uncertainty and Robustness;302 15.5.3;11.5.3 Asset-Pricing Relation;304 15.5.4;11.5.4 Equity Premium;307 15.5.5;11.5.5 Stationarity;309 15.5.6;11.5.6 Discussion;310 16;12 Retrospective Essay: Risk Assessment in Project Management;314 16.1;12.1 Info-Gap Uncertainty: What Is It?;315 16.2;12.2 Info-Gap Uncertainties in Project Management;316 16.3;12.3 Robustness: Greatest Tolerable Info-Gap;319 16.4;12.4 Value Judgments: How Robust Is Robust Enough?;320 16.5;12.5 Risk and the Robustness-vs.-Reward Trade-off;323 16.6;12.6 Improving Robustness by Gathering Information;325 16.7;12.7 Improving Robustness by Restructuring;327 16.8;12.8 What Should We Optimize?;328 16.9;12.9 The Other Face of Uncertainty: Opportuneness;330 16.10;12.10 Quantitative Decision Support Systems;332 17;13 Implications of Info-Gap Uncertainty;334 17.1;13.1 Holism and Uncertainty;335 17.2;13.2 Language, Meaning and Uncertainty;338 17.3;13.3 Warrant and Uncertainty;342 17.4;13.4 Credence for Info-Gap Inference;348 17.4.1;13.4.1 Info-Gap Inference an
d Robust Severe Tests;349 17.4.2;13.4.2 Warrant and Credence;351 17.4.3;13.4.3 Credibility of Info-Gap Inference;354 17.4.4;13.4.4 Info-Gap Inference with the Opportuneness Function;356 17.5;13.5 Risk and Uncertainty;358 18;References;364 19;Author Index;374 19.1;A;374 19.2;B;374 19.3;C;374 19.4;D;374 19.5;E;375 19.6;F;375 19.7;G;375 19.8;H;375 19.9;J;375 19.10;K;375 19.11;L;375 19.12;M;375 19.13;N;376 19.14;O;376 19.15;P;376 19.16;Q;376 19.17;R;376 19.18;S;376 19.19;T;376 19.20;V;376 19.21;W;376 19.22;Y;377 19.23;Z;377 20;Subject Index;378 20.1;A;378 20.2;B;378 20.3;C;378 20.4;D;379 20.5;E;379 20.6;F;380 20.7;G;380 20.8;H;380 20.9;I;380 20.10;K;381 20.11;L;381 20.12;M;381 20.13;N;382 20.14;O;382 20.15;P;382 20.16;Q;383 20.17;R;383 20.18;S;384 20.19;T;384 20.20;U;384 20.21;V;385 20.22;W;385