"Participation in the Münstersche Vorlesungen zur Philosophie 2005 was an honor and a genuine intellectual pleasure for me. The symposium, with all its contributions by the Münster faculty and students, was a wonderfully valuable experience. I can hardly do justice to its spirit of free discussion, or adequately express my thanks, by these short replies. But I think that they will testify clearly to the stimulation the symposium provided and to how much I learned from this exchange." Bas van Fraassen
Inhaltsverzeichnis
1;Contents ;7 2.1;Preface ;9 3.1;List of Abbreviations of Bas C. van Fraassens Publications ;11 4.1;1Science as Representation ;13 4.1.1;1.1Weyl on isomorphism ;14 4.1.2;1.2 The history behind Weyls point ;15 4.1.2.1;Lobachevsky measures ;15 4.1.2.2;Helmholtz ;16 4.1.2.3;Mathematicians reaction ;17 4.1.2.4;Philosophers reaction: There must be a fact of the matter! ;18 4.1.3;2Carnap: Der Logische Aufbau der Welt ;20 4.1.3.1;2.1The crucial problem ;21 4.1.3.2;2.2Return to the problem ;22 4.1.4;3Putnams Paradox ;25 4.1.4.1;3.1The argument ;25 4.1.4.1.1;Suppositions ;25 4.1.4.1.2;Argument ;26 4.1.4.2;3.2An example, an objection, and a realist way out (?) ;27 4.1.5;4Doing without Metaphysics ;28 4.1.5.1;4.1Asserting a relation between phenomena and model ;29 4.1.5.2;4.2Cutting through isomorphism: the Essential Indexical ;30 4.1.5.3;4.3Return to our epistemological question ;31 4.1.6;Appendix: re Putnam ;32 4.1.7;References ;34 5.1;Introduction ;35 5.2;1Constructive Empiricism and the Observable/Unobservable Distinction ;36 5.3;2Observability and the Epistemic Community ;37 5.4;3Observability and Objectivity ;40 5.5;Conclusion ;42 5.6;References ;43 6.1;1 ;45 6.2;2 ;47 6.3;3 ;52 6.4;4 ;54 6.5;References ;56 7.1;Introduction ;57 7.2;1Setting the stage ;59 7.2.1;(A)Epistemic modesty and Philosophy of Science ;59 7.2.2;(B)Constructive Empiricism and Adequacy to Science ;60 7.2.3;(C)Balancing the Elements ;61 7.2.4;2Undermining the Compromise ;62 7.2.5;Conclusion ;67 7.2.6;References ;67 8.1;Introduction ;69 8.2;1The Concept of Observation ;70 8.3;2Observability realistically construed ;74 8.4;3Running into a dilemma ;76 9.1;Introduction ;81 9.2;1Truth as Correspondence to the Real World ;82 9.3;2Truth as indexical ;85 9.4;3Remnants of Realism Observables in the Mind-Independent World ;88 9.5;References ;91 10.1;Introduction ;93 10.2;1Scientific Language ;94 10.3;2Experience and Metaphysics ;97 10.4;3Inference to the best explanation ;99 10.5;Conclusion ;100 10.6;References
;101 11.1;1Laws, Necessity, and a Dilemma ;103 11.2;2Van Fraassens skepticism about laws ;105 11.3;3About becoming a metaphysician when you do not want to ;108 11.4;References ;112 12.1;Introduction ;113 12.2;1Van Fraassens conception of a stance ;114 12.2.1;The problem: Empiricisms self-defeating argument against metaphysics ;114 12.2.2;The solution: Empiricism as a stance ;115 12.2.3;2Two accounts of possible discourse besides truth- and falsehood ;116 12.2.3.1;Consistency and a common ground ;117 12.2.3.2;Normative dimensions besides Truth- and Falsehood ;118 12.2.4;3The truth-dependence of philosophical stances ;119 12.2.4.1;Stances as policies ;119 12.2.4.2;Attitudes ;120 12.2.4.3;Values ;121 12.2.5;4Two final objections ;122 12.2.5.1;One belief or many? ;122 12.2.5.2;Teller or van Fraassen? ;123 12.2.6;Conclusion ;124 12.2.7;References ;124 13.1;Preamble: on Literate Experience and Realism ;125 13.2;1 Observability and the Epistemic Community ;128 13.2.1;1.1 Factual claims ;129 13.2.2;1.2 The factual claim of observability ;130 13.2.3;1.3 Our epistemic community ;131 13.2.4;2 To be Prussian or not to be Prussian van Fraassen and the Inference to the Best Explanation ;132 13.2.4.1;2.1 Initial arguments using IBE in support of scientific realism ;133 13.2.4.2;2.2 The best of a bad lot argument ;134 13.2.4.3;2.3 The argument from indifference ;135 13.2.4.4;2.4 Do we now have succor to offer the scientific realist? ;137 13.2.4.5;2.5 The no miracle argument how the realist begs the question ;138 13.2.5;3 The Hardships of an Empiricist van Fraassens Compromise Between Epistemic Modesty and Adequacy to Science ;141 13.2.5.1;3.1 Empiricists stake in the portrayal of science ;142 13.2.5.2;3.2 The scientists pursuit of truth ;142 13.2.5.3;3.3 A footnote to epistemic false modesty ;144 13.2.5.4;3.4 The other challenge ;144 13.2.6;4 Experience Becoming Fully Literate: van Fraassen On The Verge Of Constructivism ;146 13.2.6.1;4.1 The two faces of experience ;146 13.2.6.2;4
.2 Metaphysical realism contested ;147 13.2.6.3;4.2.1 Reification of structure ;148 13.2.6.4;4.2.2 The one true story of the world ;149 13.2.6.5;4.3 Observability is a matter of fact ;151 13.2.7;5 Indexical Truth and Anti-Metaphysical Inclinations Getting Rid of the Remnants of Realism ;152 13.2.7.1;5.1 Truth as I used to think of it ;153 13.2.7.2;5.2 What I think about truth now ;156 13.2.7.3;5.3 Making sense of The Scientific Image in retrospect ;158 13.2.8;6 Theres Life In The Old Dog Yet! van Fraassen And The Death Of Metaphysics ;159 13.2.8.1;6.1 The untold riches of metaphysics ;160 13.2.8.2;6.2 Does todays metaphysics have a different rationale? ;161 13.2.8.3;6.3 Explicanda and simulacra ;162 13.2.8.4;6.4 The metaphysical instinct ;163 13.2.9;7 Laws and Metaphysics Two Burdens Easily Discarded? ;164 13.2.9.1;7.1 The dilemma and its origin ;164 13.2.9.2;7.2 Two ways to understand the idea of laws of nature ;165 13.2.10;8 Empiricism Without Metaphysics? On van Fraassens Conception Of A Stance ;167 13.2.11;References ;171 14;CONTENTS;7 15;Blank Page;2 16;Blank Page;4