In discussion with Martin Buber, Franz Rosenzweig, Abraham Joshua Heschel, Franz Fischer and Emmanuel Levinas, Ephraim Meir outlines a novel conception of a selfhood that is grounded in dialogical thought. He focuses on the shaping of identity in present day societies and offers a new view on identity around the concepts of self-transcendence, self-difference, and trans-difference. Subjectivity is seen as the concrete possibility of relating to an open identity, which receives and hosts alterity. Self-difference is the crown upon the I; it is the result of a dialogical life, a life of passing to the other. The religious I is perceived as in dialogue with secularity, with its own past and with other persons. It is suggested that with a dialogical approach one may discover what unites people in pluralist societies.
Inhaltsverzeichnis
1;Preface;7 2;Introduction;13 3;Chapter 1;16 3.1;Elucidating Identity and Alterity;16 3.2;Views on Identity;16 3.3;Identity: A Fictitious Story?;22 3.4;Othering as Openness of the I;24 3.5;Self-Creation or Created Self?;24 3.6;The Two Sides of the Self;26 3.7;A Forgotten Horizon;28 4;The Problem of Identity in Dialogical Philosophy;33 5;Chapter 2;35 5.1;I-you and Eternal You in the Thought of Martin Buber;35 5.2;I and Ego, Person and Self-Being;35 5.3;I-you and I-it;37 5.4;Passage From I-you To I-it;38 5.5;Hesitation;40 5.6;Inter-Subjectivity and Presence, Will and Grace;43 5.7;The Eternal You;44 5.8;Revelation and Religions;46 5.9;What is Man?;51 5.10;Judaism and Zionism: Dialogical Realities;54 5.11;Zionism as Utopia;56 5.12;Judaism and Christianity;57 6;Chapter 3;60 6.1;Franz Rosenzweigs Animated I or Soul;60 6.2;The Centrality of Relationships;61 6.3;Individual and Collective Identities;61 6.4;Inclusive Thinking: Judaism and Christianity;63 6.5;The Question of Truth;65 6.6;Gritli and Franz: An Example of Dialogical Life;66 6.7;The Tragic I;68 6.8;The Transformation of the Tragic Self into a Beloved and Loving I;70 6.9;Speech and Human and Divine Love;71 6.10;Death, Love and Light;73 6.11;Between Self and Soul;74 6.12;The Other in the Self, Identity Surprised by Exteriority and Alterity;76 6.13;Turning to the World: The Process of Redemption;78 6.14;The I Beyond Itself in the We and Trans-Difference;79 6.15;The New Law as Linking Communities;79 6.16;Rosenzweigs Lehrhaus as Dialogical Enterprise;81 6.17;The New Law and the Lehrhaus;88 6.18;The House of Study and Speech Thinking;90 6.19;Translating as an Act of Peace;91 6.20;Self, Self-Transcendence and Trans-Difference;95 7;Chapter 4;97 7.1;The I as Homo Sympatheticus in Abraham Joshua Heschel;97 7.2;The I as Concern for the Non-I;98 7.3;The I and the Ineffable;98 7.4;The Prophetic I;100 7.5;Heschels Own I;101 7.6;The Sympathetic I;102 7.7;The Mystery of the Self: On the Conversion of Needs;103 7.8;The Compassiona
te I, Judaism and the World;105 7.9;Human Dignity;106 8;Chapter 5;110 8.1;Franz Fischers Proflective Thought on the I;110 8.2;Selfless Existence;111 8.3;Proflective Philosophy;112 8.4;Proligion Instead of Religion;114 8.5;Xenology;115 8.6;Fischer and Buber on the Other;116 8.7;Specificity of the Self versus Selflessness;116 8.8;Christianity as Hospitality;117 9;Chapter 6;118 9.1;Emmanuel Levinass One-For-the-Other;118 9.2;The I as Agent or as Called;119 9.3;Buber and Levinas;121 9.4;Self-Transcendence in Fecundity;122 9.5;Death and Time;123 9.6;Rosenzweig and Levinas;125 9.7;Society and Ethics;126 9.8;Limitless Freedom and Difficult Freedom;127 9.9;Reason and Pre-Conceptual Demands;128 9.10;Goodness Beyond Systems;128 9.11;Rights of the Other Man and Rights of Man;129 9.12;Heschel and Levinas;130 9.13;Judaism as Category of Being;131 9.14;Hebrew Identity as Fraternity;132 9.15;Jewish Education and Anti-Humanism;133 9.16;Jewish Suffering and Jewish Anti-Totalitarianism;134 9.17;Talmud Torah;136 9.18;Judaism and Rationality, Recognition and Cognition;138 9.19;Building Blocks;140 10;Self-Transcendence, Self-Difference, and Trans-Difference. Philosophical and Theological Considerations;143 11;Chapter 7;145 11.1;The Non-Identical I;145 11.2;Radical Difference;147 11.3;Trans-Difference;149 11.4;Avoiding Extreme Assimilation and Extreme Dissimilation;149 11.5;Different Kinds of Trans-Difference;150 11.6;The Case of the Convert;152 11.7;Transcending the Self;154 11.8;The Ethical Dimension of the Self;156 11.9;To Do the Good for its own Sake or not for its own Sake;158 11.10;Nomadic Existence in Self-Difference;160 11.11;Either Post-Difference or Inbetweenness;163 11.12;The Theater of Identity;164 11.13;Judaism Otherwise;165 11.14;Jewish Particularity;168 11.15;Converted Thoughts;171 11.16;Conversion and Conversation;173 11.17;Religious Identity, the Past and the Future, the Same and the Other;174 11.18;Other-Oriented and World-Oriented Religion;175 11.19;Religious Pluralism
;177 11.20;The Dialogical Self and Intercultural Communication;179 11.21;Beyond Relativism and Absolutism;182 11.22;Dialogue Beyond Identity;183 11.23;The Challenge of Meta-Identical Religiosity for Conflict Resolution;186 11.24;Religious Violence;189 11.25;Self-Narrative and Narrative of the Other;190 11.26;Reflection, Turning and the Search for the Deeper Self;193 12;Chapter 8;195 12.1;The Interpreted and Interpreting I;195 12.2;The Idea of Election or the I as Interpreted by the Other;196 12.3;The I in Travail with the Other;197 12.4;Loving the Other;200 12.5;Global Consciousness versus Universal Consciousness;201 12.6;Jewish Alterity and Larger Society: Dissimilation in Assimilation;203 12.7;Jews, jews and the Law;205 12.8;Lessing and Beyond, Unity and Diversity;206 12.9;Dialogical Hermeneutics;212 12.10;The New Dialogue Between Secularism and Religion;218 12.11;Reinterpreting Traditional Religious Concepts;220 12.12;Interaction Between Religion and Secular Modernity;223 12.13;Combining Libraries versus the All-Encompassing Library of Babel;224 12.14;One Voice and a Multitude of Books;227 12.15;Combining Cultures and Sharing Gods Care for the Human Being;230 12.16;Love God With All Your Heart;233 12.17;Interpreting With the Other in Mind;234 13;Bibliography;236 14;Index of Names;243